5 Best Hotels in Middlebury, Indiana - Book Now

Middlebury boasts landmarks like the historic Bonneyville Mill and the scenic Maple Acres Park, alongside river kayaking at the Elkhart River. This city provides a mix of hotels, from charming B&Bs to cozy motels-all carefully selected based on guest reviews and their top amenities. You can find a curated list of hotels that offer unique local experiences and comfort. Remember to book during summer or fall for the best rates. For easy travel, consider using the local bus service or enjoying a bike ride through the town.

1-5 out of 5

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

8.4

Great

Essenhaus Inn & Conf. Center Middlebury

MapAmish Country300m

Indoor pool with therapeutic hot tub
On-site dining with German cuisine
Bicycle rental for outdoor exploration

Indoor Pool
Fitness Centre
On-site Dining

Hotel showcasing unique Amish culture and leisure activities

FromUS$ 122 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Hampton Inn & Suites Middlebury

MapNestled in Amish country0m

Indoors heated pool and spa area
Variety of breakfast options daily
Family-friendly atmosphere and amenities

Indoor Pool
Business Area
Fitness Centre

Hotel offering family-focused amenities and comfort

FromUS$ 110 /nightSelect

The Wellington Lake Cottage

MapScenic lake views100m

Rooms with modern amenities and air conditioning
Outdoor activities like fishing and canoeing available
On-site games room and picnic area for families

Game room
Outdoor fireplace
Water sports

Family-friendly resort with water sports activities

Select

Lakin' It Easy

MapMidwest Museum of American Art35km

Rooms with lake views
Outdoor dining area
Family-friendly play area

Air conditioning
Outdoor fireplace
Fully equipped kitchen

Holiday home with outdoor amenities and scenic views

FromUS$ 204 /nightSelect

Charming Middlebury Retreat W/ Patio & Fire Pit

MapNearby Midwest Museum of American Art20km

Three bedrooms and three bathrooms
Private terrace for outdoor relaxation
Equipped kitchen for home cooking

Private entrance
Outdoor patio
Fire pit

Spacious holiday home with modern amenities and charm

Select

Places to stay near Middlebury

Cozy Amish Country Cabin On Shipshewana Lake!

Picturesque Amish countryside300m

Relaxing hot tub and jacuzzi available
Beautiful lake view balcony for guests
Spacious kitchen with modern appliances

Hot Tub
Lake Views
Full Kitchen

Charming lakefront holiday home in Amish Country

FromUS$ 262 /nightSelect

Charming Dairy Farm Home In Indiana Amish Country Shipshewana

Amish culture and local attractions33km

Three cozy bedrooms for family gatherings
Fully equipped kitchen for cooking meals
Fitness centre for exercise enthusiasts

Fitness centre
Free parking
Kitchen utensils

Holiday home in scenic Indiana Amish countryside

FromUS$ 127 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

Farmstead Inn And Conference Center Shipshewana

Opposite Shipshewana Auction100m

Indoor pool and basketball court
Complimentary hot breakfast buffet
Spacious family-friendly rooms

Indoor Pool
Fitness Center
Event Space

Hotel with unique Amish country experience and events

FromUS$ 92 /nightSelect

Blue Birds Perch: Stunning Home On Private Hilltop Shipshewana

Midwest Museum of American Art36km

Four spacious rooms with three bathrooms
Private entrance with modern amenities
On-site parking for guests

Fully equipped kitchen
Flat-screen TV
Private entrance

Holiday home with private hilltop views and comfort

FromUS$ 254 /nightSelect

8.2

Great

Super 8 By Wyndham Shipshewana Hotel

Close to Shipshewana Auction200m

Complimentary grab and go breakfast offered daily
Located next to Shipshewana Town Center events
Easy access to nearby flea market attractions

Free Parking
Pet Friendly
Air Conditioning

Family-friendly hotel in the heart of Amish country

FromUS$ 73 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Middlebury

A world of accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly stays to luxurious retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's dream vacation.

⬆️ The highest price

USD 204

⬇️ The lowest price

USD 110

💸 Average price for

3-star hotels

USD 116

Best hotels in Middlebury

Based on guest reviews over the last 12 months

Comfort and Convenience:

Hampton Inn & Suites Middlebury

Relaxation and Retreat:

Essenhaus Inn & Conf. Center

FAQs about hotels in Middlebury

We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip

Which hotel properties in Middlebury offer the best value for money?

The Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center and Hampton Inn & Suites Middlebury are the two main options. Rates at the Hampton Inn typically range from $120 to $180 per night, while Essenhaus offers rooms starting at around $130, making them competitive with nearby accommodations.

Which hotels in Middlebury are best for families?

Both the Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center and Hampton Inn & Suites are family-friendly. The Hampton Inn features an indoor pool and complimentary breakfast, while Essenhaus has spacious rooms and family amenities.

Which Middlebury hotels are closest to popular landmarks?

Hampton Inn & Suites is roughly 1.5 km from the Girl of the Wabash and Essenhaus Inn is about 4 km from the Amish Acres, making both conveniently located for sightseeing.

Which hotel in Middlebury offers unique views?

The Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center features scenic views of the surrounding Amish countryside, making it more appealing for those seeking picturesque settings.

What hotels in Middlebury are suitable for couples?

The Essenhaus Inn & Conference Center is ideal for couples, providing a romantic atmosphere with beautiful surroundings and options for dining at the on-site restaurant.

Exploring Hotels in Middlebury, Vermont

This guide provides essential details on hotel accommodations in Middlebury, evaluating 2 properties with a focus on pricing, location, and seasonal tips to aid your travel planning.

Typical nightly prices range from $150 to $250 USD.

There are 2 hotels evaluated in Middlebury.

Peak travel seasons are summer (June to August) and fall (September to October).

Local taxes/fees average around 10%.

Both properties are within 1 km of Middlebury College and historic downtown.

Hotels in Middlebury, Indiana

Only Handpicked and Verified Accommodations for Your Stay in Middlebury, United States

Places to stay near Middlebury

Shipshewana5 properties

Price range for hotels in Middlebury

Best hotels in Middlebury

FAQs about hotels in Middlebury

Exploring Hotels in Middlebury, Vermont

Other cities in United States